Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop

Discover delicious, crispy pizza, hearty pasta, and authentic Italian favorites at Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop in Dover, OH. Enjoy homemade spaghetti, meatballs, cannoli, breadsticks, and more in our family-friendly local spot. Call +1 330-343-3512 today!

Welcome to Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop

Taste the Difference.

Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop
Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop
Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop
Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop

Nestled in the heart of Dover, Ohio, Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop serves mouth-watering pizza and pasta that feels just like home. This cozy mom-and-pop establishment captures the essence of Italian comfort food. As you step inside, the fragrant aroma of baked dough and simmering sauce invites you to indulge in their signature dishes. Diners rave about the spaghetti with meatballs and the crispy pizza loaded with fresh toppings. This charming shop is the perfect spot for a family dinner, a quick bite, or a casual meal with friends. Mary Zifer's blends quality ingredients with a friendly atmosphere, making it a beloved local treasure that never disappoints.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

110 W 4th St, Dover, OH 44622, United States

Phone

+1 330-343-3512

About

The Culinary Story

Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop
Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop
Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop
Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop

Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop has been serving the Dover community with commitment and passion, showcasing the tradition of Italian cuisine. Its legacy stems from a desire to create a friendly neighborhood environment where everyone feels like family. The local essence of this pizza shop shines through its homemade sauces and dough, all prepared daily.

Customers flock to Mary Zifer's for a taste of simplicity and familiarity. The menu highlights beloved Italian staples, ensuring each dish is made with love—from the fresh salads to the bountiful pasta offerings. Each bite transports you back to comforting family gatherings and shared meals, a feeling that resonates deeply with locals.

The atmosphere of Mary Zifer's enhances the dining experience. Cozy booths and warm decor invite patrons to relax and enjoy their meals in a welcoming environment. The walls often display local art or photographs, creating a sense of community pride. This establishment stands out as a gathering hub for friends and families alike.

Diners enjoy the camaraderie of a local pizza spot where the staff knows regulars by name. Mary Zifer's also embraces special community events, frequently collaborating with local schools and charities. Whether it’s a pizza night fundraiser or holiday celebration, the spirit of togetherness remains strong here, embodying the heart of Dover. Delivering great food, community connection, and a taste of home, Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop continues to thrive and grow.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-10 PM

Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop boasts a diverse menu that has something for everyone. From delicious appetizers like garlic bread and cheesy breadsticks to their standout meatball splash sandwich, tastebuds are in for a treat. The pasta dishes include classic offerings like rigatoni and regular pasta, perfect for those who appreciate hearty meals. The prices are wallet-friendly, averaging just over $5, allowing diners to enjoy quality meals without breaking the bank.

For dessert, make sure to try the famous canolis and delectable brownies, adding a sweet finish to your dining experience. Customers can opt for dine-in or carryout, catering to your dining preference. The restaurant's peak times indicate how popular it is—especially on Fridays, when the place fills to 100% capacity. Plan accordingly to avoid the crowds.

Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop

The exterior of Mary Zifer's Pizza Shop is unassuming yet appealing, with a classic storefront that invites passersby in. Bright signage and a welcoming facade hint at the vibrant atmosphere within. The outdoor seating area allows patrons to enjoy al fresco dining during pleasant weather, making it a popular spot for locals.

As customers enter, a friendly ambiance greets them, capturing the essence of a true neighborhood eatery. Children laugh, families gather, and friends share stories, all creating a lively environment that embraces community spirit.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Excellent pizza at a reasonable price! It's good family dining.

D
Dan H.

The best pizza and pasta in Dover , Ohio . I would recommend it to anyone.

J
Joseph A.

The food and service were absolutely amazing!!! Will definitely be back next year on our way thru for our travel softball Outlaws day!! This is truly worth the stop!!!

H
Helen T.

I love the pizza, pasta, and salads. I love that first bite of the pizza crunch!

E
Elizabeth L.

Nice "mom and pop" shop. Food was good and server was friendly and efficient. The pizza is made with colby cheese. Gives it a slightly different flavor. Unique.

S
Sharon L.

If you come to Tuscarawas county you have to try this pizza. Its just amazing and so unique. Nice little restaurant, great fun servers. Prices are very reasonable and they are super quick and there salad dressing is awesome!

H
Heather P.